Katz's Delicatessen - New York City - USA

Deli institution or tourist trap?

If you’re visiting New York City and hoping to experience its food culture, Katz’s Delicatessen will likely be high on your list. Known for its legendary pastrami sandwiches, this Lower East Side institution has become synonymous with classic NYC dining. But while it’s undeniably famous, there’s a real case to be made that Katz’s is overrated, especially when you factor in the price, wait times, and overall experience.

Katz’s pastrami is undeniably delicious – thick, juicy cuts of meat with a smoky, slightly peppery crust. The sandwiches are packed to the brim, and the meat practically melts in your mouth. However, the high price tag (around $25 for a sandwich) can be a shock, especially for those who aren’t hardcore pastrami fans. The flavor is great, but is it worth the hype and the hefty price? For some, it might be, but for others, the experience doesn’t quite justify it.

Katz’s is famous for its old-school vibe, complete with vintage signage, cramped seating, and bustling crowds. But this charm wears thin when you’re battling with throngs of tourists for a table. The ticket system – where you’re handed a small ticket upon entering and use it to order your food – is confusing for first-timers and can be stressful during peak hours. The deli is almost always packed, and the experience can feel more like a theme park than a place to enjoy a meal.

Katz’s Delicatessen is a New York institution, and it’s worth visiting once for the novelty and history. But in terms of actual value and experience, it doesn’t always live up to the hype. For New Yorkers and food enthusiasts looking for a top-notch deli experience, there are lesser-known spots that offer similar quality without the tourist trap vibe or the steep prices.

In conclusion, Katz’s is a must-try for visitors, but it's safe to say the deli is somewhat overrated – a bucket list item rather than a place you’d return to again and again.

Personal score

Service                          5.2/10

Atmosphere.                  6.5/10

Food.                             8.4/10

Overall experience.    20.1/30